Friday, March 13, 2020

Investigating Rick Ballan's Pythagorean Wave science analysis: Why we can't SEE time

Fundamental Axioms of Wave Theory (or The Music of Science: an Acknowledgement of Pythagoras as the Founder of Science, Long Overdue).

So this is a very fascinating science analysis. The assumption first of all is that time can be seen as a spatial graph for sine waves. Let's see where he goes with this (the standard science assumption, of course). He is then retroactivately reducing science to its core principles of time and frequency as per the standard Pythagorean interpretation (from Philolaus and Archytas).

 


 So here he avoids using the Perfect Fifth and Perfect Fourth as those intervals would reveal the noncommutative phase of time and frequency in relation to the octave. Instead the octave is already assumed to be a "key" based on the assumption of the ratio as an enclosed geometry. I went over in my early analysis on Archtyas - from 15 years ago - how it was the extension of the Pythagorean Tetraktys to 1:2:3:4:5 that enabled the use of the Golden Ratio 8:5 or 4:5 inverted with 5/4 as the cube root of two (for the Renaissance precision depth and catapult technology) to then cover up the noncommutative phase truth of reality.

In other words 5:8 can not be used for 4/5 since inverting the denominator of the ratio then changes the octave or "cycle" unit equivalency. Archtyas understood this, as well as Philolaus. The Order of the ratios is what defines their value - forward and backwards time could not be allowed to exist AT THE SAME TIME.

So then for the geometric argument to hold valid then zero must be first assumed to exist as a materialistic idealism - as the objective reference frame of spacetime measurement.



The above argument then assumes that phase as the complementary opposite unity of time/frequency together can not exist on its own term! Frequency must only be defined in relation to a geometric definition of time as a wavenumber - so that a cycle of time also must increase a cycle in space.

So then the "carrier wave" has to be limited to the speed of light as the geometric velocity of space for the invariant unit of science. Rick Ballan corroborates this "truth" of standard symmetric math science:

 


Whereas time itself is not limited by the speed of light as a materialistic photon definition. Since light has no rest mass therefore its "space" originates from time itself that inherently can not be seen - as the 5th dimension. As Astrophysics professor Paul S. Wesson emphasized - this means that all matter in the Universe is made of light and is actually all happening (the future and past) at the SAME time (from the perspective of spirit or light itself).

Yet since light also has relativistic mass, as astrophysics professor - what's his name in India - has emphasized - the mass of light is from noncommutative phase as non-local spacetime.

I'll keep reading - Oh the name...

B.G. Sidharth

 "Therefore, the underlying geometry behind the superluminal nature of a particle is simply the noncommutative geometry."
OK let's continue.....

"Returning to the mass of the photon, it can be argued that this is a result of the non commutativity of spacetime at a micro scale." B.G. Sidharth




says Rick Ballan - are those really are ONLY two choices about time?

I would think a musician might favor LISTENING to the SOURCE of time - without any predisposition about any rate



Oops - a convenient ignorance of noncommutative phase from the Perfect Fifth to the Octave?




Really? This is silly. Why is he "adding" the interval in "zero time" when it is added in real time. So that playing it "backwards" would be to reverse the intervals! So playing a G to C is a Perfect Fourth while playing a C to G is a Perfect Fifth! Only a person not trained in music would fall for the above argument! He is trying to fool non-musicians?




Precisely! So why is he refusing to acknowledge that G to C is not the same time reversal as C to G? One is a Perfect Fourth and the other is a Perfect Fifth!!

So then after claiming to promote a cyclic "wave" theory of reality he suddenly falls back onto irrational numbers - and (he has no choice since he's relying on standard symmetric math FIRST to define his supposed music Pythagorean view of reality).




Yes but Kurt Godel proved that Cantor could not prove that the irrational numbers are an actual "set" in geometry and therefore have to remain unproven - or math is inherently inconsistent. And therefore math is actually an "applied" tool of engineering - not a "pure" science of logic. And also Noncommutative Phase, as Alain Connes emphasizes is MORE DENSE than irrational numbers - and therefore a greater infinity than irrational numbers! Connes states music theory PROVES this noncommutative phase truth of reality. Oops.



Notice the logical error Rick Ballan makes - he is assuming that we have to SEE time.

"For everywhere we see that this 'time' actually does,


So maybe Rick Ballan doesn't realize that the false cadence he's referring to - what I studied while in high school - in my private training - is actually reliant on the square root of two mathematically. So he is simply talking about the "Power Axiom Set" that Bartok supposedly relied on as well - as I studied in my first year of college, using Erno Lendvai's book on the Golden Ratio in Bartok's music. In other words - this supposed symmetric mathematics is simply CREATED by the equal-tempered music tuning itself from the Tritone music interval in the "false cadence" harmonics (called the flat sixth chords).

So he's using circular reasoning by first claiming that standard Fourier analysis can't capture music subjective listening - when that subjective listening is already dependent on the equal-tempered tuning that is the foundation of the Fourier analysis! Then he says by converting the separate series into a single series - then the two can be unified. But he is neglecting the fact that quantum mechanics disproved that time is commutative! So therefore the reversal of the order of time changes its value and this is also found in the true natural harmonics of the PErfect Fifth to the Octave via the Perfect Fourth.

So when Ballan states there can be no "instantaneous frequency" - this is simply restating the time-frequency uncertainty principle.

The question then is what does "instantaneous time" mean in reference to itself as a cycle? We know from quantum physics that for a cycle of time the spin is defined as 1/2 spin such that the cycle has to invert itself to return back to itself - via 720 degrees (NOT 360 degrees) - thereby creating the 5th dimension of space that can not be seen at the SAME time (yet it can be logically inferred and listened to). So then instantaneous time is a black hole/white hole as the 5th dimension aka consciousness - the pilot wave - and is noncommutative phase as the origin of the time-frequency uncertainty principle.

https://www.academia.edu/11287719/Do_Matter_Anti-Matter_Standing_Waves_Exceed_the_Speed_of_Light

Here Rick Ballan does realize the reality of superluminal energy as the guiding force from the future - reverse time energy - the basis of de Broglie's Law of Phase Harmony - and why science can not accept this. thanks for the fascinating analysis!


Rick Ballan | BA, BeD , BM. | The University of Sydney, Sydney ...


A professional musician and honorary research associate of the University of Sydney who is interested in the field of wave analysis and modelling, particularly ...
About Rick. Jazz guitarist, composer, arranger, painter. Also does research in the Auditory neuroscience lab at the university of Sydney. Favorite Quotes




https://www.academia.edu/11283333/Time_Contraction_in_the_Two_Mirror_Proof_of_Special_Relativity

This paper is very similar to one I cite (Steven M. Taylor) in my de Broglie compilation...

http://ecoechoinvasives.blogspot.com/2018/01/summarizing-de-broglie-pilot-wave-law.html

See the final post on Rick Ballan.

I sent the Steven M. Taylor paper to Rick Ballan.
























No comments:

Post a Comment