Data collected in vivo and in vitro show that sound vibrations can influence the growth, structure, and behavior of cells [72,73,74]. This suggests that psychic activity and its language can determine biochemical changes (and vice versa), and therefore have a biological impact on specific diseases and therapies [72,73,74], confirming the connection between neuronal activity and somatic, phonetic, perceptive, and emotional activity [75]. Acoustic and electromagnetic waves, such as those of the heart–brain axis, can determine the dynamics and structure of cells and their components.
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUuw3QyGKwR4
The action of sounds may induce a breakdown of this dipole symmetry by producing a non-vanishing polarization density P(x,t) (dipole ordering). The dipole long-range correlations arising in such a process of symmetry breakdown generate the collective, coherent behavior of the system components, which manifests in the macroscopic scale behavior of the observed cellular structures and cell network....
. They constitute about 90% of the present molecules of the studied system. In the initial step, the input sounds induce, as mentioned, the breakdown of the dipole spherical symmetry by producing, if a ‘good’ sound (or contrasting, if a ‘bad’ sound), the dipole polarization density P(x,t). The dynamical effect following from the SBS is the formation of long-range dipole correlations resulting in the “in-phase” collective motion of the dipoles (ordering). The value of P(x,t) gives a measure of the degree of ordering induced by SBS and is indeed called the order parameter [14,15].
The quanta associated with the long-range correlations, called Nambu–Goldstone (NG) quanta, have zero mass and integer spin (are bosons), which means that a large number of them may condense in the ground state of the system, forming a coherent state. ‘Coherent’ means that long-range correlations coexist in that state without negative interferences. They are long-range “phase correlations” among oscillating molecular dipoles.
https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/23/9/5145#Conclusions_a5
https://rosa.uniroma1.it/rosa04/organisms/article/download/19448/17521
The experimentally widely tested Goldstone
theorem holds in QFT. It states that when spontaneous
breakdown of symmetry occurs, then gapless quanta are
dynamically generated in the system (Itzykson & Zuber
1980; Umezawa 1993; Blasone, Jizba, & Vitiello 2011).
These gapless quanta are called Nambu-Goldstone
(NG) quanta, or field. Gapless means that the energy
of these fields does not get contributions from mass
terms. The wavelength associated to them (through
the de Broglie relation) goes to infinity in the limit of
zero momentum. This means that NG boson fields thus
represent long-range correlations among the system
elementary constituents. Their presence in the ground
state is denoted by the term “condensation” and it
is ruled by the Bose-Einstein statistics. When there
is no negative interferences among the long-range
correlations associated to NG, one says that these
correlations are coherent ones, and there is ‘coherent
condensation’ in the ground state.
Well-known examples of NG boson quanta are the
magnons in magnets, the phonons in crystals, and
dipole wave quanta in dipolar systems. These behave
just as quantum particles “within” the observed system.
Therefore, they can be considered as (structural)
effective elementary components of the system,
describing its microscopic dynamics together with the
other elementary components (Umezawa 1993; Vitiello
1998; Blasone, Jizba, & Vitiello 2011). Their presence
can be detected by means of scattering techniques,
yielding a corresponding spectrum (Del Giudice et al.
1988; Arani et al. 1995; Wolfe 1998; Del Giudice &
Vitiello 2006; Giudice, Spinetti, & Tedeschi 2010; Bono
et al. 2012); however, they are “confined” within the
system, i.e., they do not propagate outside it.
An important remark about the coherent
condensation of NG bosons in the ground state, is that
their associated long-range correlations generate the
ordering of the system’s elementary components,
specific of the case (geometric, magnetic, rotational,
electric, etc.), and, consequently, the macroscopic
structure of the system. Order’s appearance is thus a
result of the coherent condensation of NG bosons in
the ground state, resulting in turn from spontaneous
breakdown of symmetry. Order is therefore lack of
symmetry.
https://rosa.uniroma1.it/rosa04/organisms/article/download/19448/17521
*
a Dipartimento di Medicina, Università degli Studi di Padova, Via Giustininani 2, 35100, Padova, Italy and Fondazione Mikhael, Via Moratti
6, 35010, Borgoricco (Padova), Italy
a Dipartimento di Fisica “E.R. Caianiello”, Università di Salerno, Via Giovanni Paolo II, 132, 84084, Fisciano (Salerno), Italy
*Corresponding author: Carlo Dal Lin, Email: carlodallin@libero.it
Abstract
In this work, we present a brief overview of our research on the Relaxation Response (RR) in healthy subjects and in patients with myocardial infarction. The practice of techniques employed to elicit the RR is associated with the laboratory observation of very rapid and uniform changes in a multitude of molecular species. As far as we know, no
literature exists on the temporal dynamics of these changes in terms of simple stochastic diffusive processes or by
Coulomb-type electrostatic interactions alone. The results we observed suggest, as a working hypothesis, a description
in terms of collective coherent behavior of microscopic components, a description generally and successfully adopted
in modern many-body physics. We therefore turned to consider the environment in which the molecules we have
studied are embedded, namely, water. We examined several water electrodynamic properties in relation to a
theoretical model that may account for its state changes and possible interactions with solutes. From this framework,
a plausible view of the living system is the one in which the relationships among the parts, i.e., their collective
coherent behavior, rather than the individual components themselves, may account for the manifestation of multiple
properties (perception, language, semantic responsiveness to the environment, rather than mere “reaction”). Finally,
our discussion leads us to the hypothesis that the heart may play a role in orchestrating the collective coherent
behavior of the various parts and organs within the human body, and their rhythmic-functional stability.
Keywords: Relaxation Response; water; quantum electrodynamics; quantum field theory coherence
Citation: Dal Lin, C and Vitiello, G 2026 “A Review of the Results Obtained over Ten Years of Research on the Relaxation
Response and its Quantum Field Theory Framework”, Organisms. Journal of Biological Sciences, vol. 9, no. 2, pp. 23–49. DOI:
10.13133/2532-5876/19448
Reviews
Vol. 9, No. 2 (2026)
ISSN: 2532-5876
Open access journal licensed under CC-BY
DOI: 10.13133/2532-5876/19448
QFT coherence, once triggered, even by a very
weak stimulus, is very robust and may well survive in a
hot, wet, noisy, and hostile environment.
the energy need for a ionization electron is quite
low (0.55eV). This means that under such conditions,
CDs [nonlocal coherent domains] can easily be sources of quasi-free (ionization)
electrons; a very convenient scenario for biochemical
activity, electrons being the ‘exchange currency’
promoting chemical interactions
BUILDING ON THE WORK OF EMILIO DEL GiuDICE!!
As for the electrons, an analogous reasoning
applies to proton oscillations (Ho 2008). Within the
CD, electronic charges associated with the various
possible excitation levels may find a superconductive
state (Del Giudice et al. 1988; Del Giudice & Vitiello
2006). Moreover, different synchronization patterns
can be established among water molecules, even those
belonging to different coherence domains, thereby
forming CDs over extended regions. The energy
absorbed by the system cannot be released as heat, but
only as work or enthalpy, provided that a suitable partner
is available. This principle gives rise to supercoherence
(Del Giudice et al. 2005):
t has been shown (Del Giudice, Doglia, & Milani
1986) that in coherently fully polarized water, the self-
focusing threshold energy is 13.60 eV, depending on
the water molecular polarization P(x,t), on the water
molecular electric dipole, and on the electron mass
and charge. The diameter of the tubular ‘channel’ is
computed to be 147 Å, in excellent agreement with the
observed diameter of a microtubule in cytoskeletal
structures (tubulin microtubules, kinesin, actin,
myosin, etc.) (Cifra, Fields, & Farhadi 2011). Notably,
no other quantitative analysis in biology can currently
predict the internal diameter of microtubules (Del
Giudice, Doglia, & Milani 1986).
The EM field confined within the filament produces
field gradients at its boundaries (outside the filament
there is no EM field), giving rise to attractive or
repulsive forces that attract or repel molecules able
to resonate with the EM field, thereby creating a local
enrichment of reactants along microtubules, collagen
fibers, hyaluronic polymers, and actin.
This might also explain the process of coating of the
filament by tubulin molecules. Microtubules are indeed
composed of two different conformational types of
tubulin, alpha and beta, which allow them to interlock in
a helical arrangement. The electric potential generated
by the tubulin longitudinal pulsations induces an
asymmetric and saw tooth-like motion (Astumian 1997;
Cifra, Fields, & Farhadi 2011) (cf. Fig. 9) on a charge
moving along the tubulin chain. A “ratchet” mechanism is
thus established—a stepwise, rack-and-pawl dynamics
t has been shown (Del Giudice et al. 1985) that
non-linear molecular interaction in cytoskeletal protein
polymer, embedded in coherent water, may sustain
the dynamic formation of soliton waves, namely of
a spatially confined collective phonon excitation,
that does not “spread out” in its high speed over the
polymer, neither deforms or collapses by interacting
with other solitons and is able to self-regenerating
from environmental noise perturbations. The soliton
may also transport kinesin along the microtubule (and
potentially induce actin-myosin coupling), see Fig. 10.
The formation of spatial regions filled with multiple
CDs (supercoherence) may arise only in the presence
of other species/solutes,
Breaking of continuous
symmetry is in conclusion a prerequisite for the
emergence of ordered ‘pathways’ in biological systems
(biochemical reactions and the compartmentalization
of functional domains) that strive to maintain vital
homeostasis..... a coherent
dipole wave quanta condensate.
We have proposed that the heart,
understood as both an EM field and an anatomical-
physiological morphology, “conducts” the bodily
orchestra. In this view, the heart acts as the primary
generator of a large-scale EM field (modulated by its beat-to-beat different contractions). This is capable
of generating vortices and acoustic fields, and of
anticipating the brain in perceptual operations, thereby
constraining brain activity as a function of the cardiac
cycle (Dal Lin, Tona, & Osto 2018; Dal Lin et al. 2021;
Keppler 2023)
Dal Lin, C, Gola, E, Brocca, A, Rubino, G, Marinova, M,
Brugnolo, L, Plebani, M, Iliceto, S, & Tona, F 2018 “miRNAs
may change rapidly with thoughts: The Relaxation
Response after myocardial infarction”, European Journal
of Integrative Medicine, vol. 20 (March), pp. 63–72.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eujim.2018.03.009.
Of particular interest is the finding that the auditory
stimuli used to induce RR (phonemes and musical
sounds) exhibit fractal structure (Dal Lin, Radu et
al. 2020; Dal Lin, Romano, Iliceto, Tona, & Vitiello
2022). Acoustic spectral analysis of these sounds
has demonstrated their capacity to modulate the
contractility of HL1 cardiomyocytes in culture,
affecting cytoskeletal organization (Dal Lin, Radu et
al. 2020). This finding further corroborates the in
vivo observations (Dal Lin, Marinova et al. 2018),
namely the improvement in cardiac performance
during the practice of RR (Figure 1-A). Sound waves
behave as pressure waves that can regulate cellular
behavior through mechanotransduction (Wang,
Tytell, & Ingber 2009).
- The Lie Algebra. \(\text{SU}(2)\) is generated by three operators (\(J_1, J_2, J_3\)), which are proportional to the Pauli matrices. They obey the noncommutative relation \([J_i, J_j] = i \epsilon_{ijk} J_k\).
- Physical Analogy. Just as rotating a 3D book 90 degrees forward and then 90 degrees right yields a different orientation than doing it in the reverse order, \(\text{SU}(2)\) transformations depend on order. Because the generators do not commute, a quantum system cannot simultaneously have definite values for all three spin components, leading to the uncertainty principle for angular momentum. [1, 2, 3]
- Noncommutative Spacetime (\([x^\mu, x^\nu] = i\theta^{\mu\nu}\)). When spatial coordinates do not commute, the constant tensor \(\theta ^{\mu \nu }\) acts like a fixed background field (similar to a constant magnetic field). This picks out a preferred direction in space, explicitly breaking continuous rotational \(\text{SO}(3)\) and \(\text{SU}(2)\) spin symmetry down to a smaller subgroup.
- Anisotropic Interactions (Explicit Breaking). In spin systems (like the Heisenberg model), the Hamiltonian is \(\text{SU}(2)\)-symmetric because interactions are equal in all directions (\(J_x = J_y = J_z\)). If you introduce directional anisotropy (\(J_z \neq J_x, J_y\)), the Hamiltonian no longer commutes with the total spin generators (\([H, J_{x,y}] \neq 0\)). This noncommutativity with the Hamiltonian explicitly breaks the continuous \(\text{SU}(2)\) symmetry down to a single \(\text{U}(1)\) rotational symmetry around the z-axis. [1]
- Quantum Deformations (\(q\)-Deformed \(\text{SU}(2)\)). In mathematical physics, altering the standard commutation relations of \(\text{SU}(2)\) using a deformation parameter \(q\) turns the continuous Lie group into a quantum group (\(\text{SU}_q(2)\)). This breaks the standard continuous symmetry into a deformed, discrete-like algebraic structure used in integrable systems and quantum gravity.
- Ground State Selection. The system's lowest-energy vacuum state chooses a single direction (e.g., all spins pointing along the z-axis).
- Loss of Commuting Generators. The vacuum state is no longer annihilated by \(J_{1}\) and \(J_{2}\) (which fail to commute with the remaining unbroken generator \(J_{3}\)). By Goldstone's theorem, these two broken noncommuting directions generate two massless excitations (Goldstone bosons or spin waves)
Spontaneous symmetry breaking in noncommutative field theories
… for slowly varying superfields so that the Goldstone theorem holds true. We also find a
new purely noncommutative coupling which gives contributions starting at order N 2 loops. …Cite Cited by 30 Related articles All 16 versionsValidity of Goldstone theorem at two loops in noncommutative U (N) linear sigma model
Y Liao - Nuclear Physics B, 2002 - Elsevier… theory is ultraviolet (UV) quadratically divergent on ordinary spacetime. On noncommutative
(NC) … In spontaneous symmetry breaking theory this would invalidate the Goldstone theorem …Cite Cited by 11 Related articles All 9 versionsNoncommutative field theory and spontaneous symmetry breaking
BA Campbell, K Kaminsky - Nuclear Physics B, 2000 - Elsevier… simplest case of the (noncommutative) linear sigma model. … of Goldstone’s theorem at one-loop
for the noncommutative … the theory, and the persistence of Goldstone’s theorem ensuring …Cite Cited by 65 Related articles All 8 versionsUV/IR mixing and the Goldstone theorem in noncommutative field theory
FR Ruiz - Nuclear Physics B, 2002 - ElsevierNoncommutative IR singularities and UV/IR mixing in relation with the Goldstone theorem for
complex scalar field theory … 2 , associated to the two noncommutative extensions φ ∗ ★φ★…Cite Cited by 34 Related articles All 14 versionsNoncommutative linear sigma models
BA Campbell, K Kaminsky - Nuclear Physics B, 2001 - Elsevier… have shown that Nambu–Goldstone symmetry realization is … Goldstone's theorem at one-loop
for the U(N) models with the quartic term ordering consistent with possible noncommutative …Cite Cited by 27 Related articles All 6 versionsVacuum configurations for renormalizable non-commutative scalar models
A de Goursac, A Tanasa, JC Wallet - The European Physical Journal C, 2008 - Springer… It is this what we propose as a corresponding Goldstone theorem in our case. Furthermore
we also allow for the possibility Ω = 0 (the fields π are non-massive and they have no …Spontaneous symmetry breaking in twisted noncommutative quantum theories
AP Balachandran, TR Govindarajan, S Vaidya - Physical Review D—Particles …, 2009 - APS… We also derive Goldstone’s theorem on Moyal spacetime. … The extension to the (noncommutative)
standard model and … II, we will review twisted quantization on noncommutative spaces …Cite Cited by 21 Related articles All 12 versionsNoncummutative Field Theories and Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking
B Campbell, K Kaminsky - Fundamental Interactions, 2002 - World Scientific… Secondly, in commutative theories, Goldstone's theorem at … seen that already in
noncommutative (p4 theory, the graphs … )] 2 in the corresponding noncommutative gauge theory, …Cite Related articles All 4 versionsNoncommutative field theory of the Tkachenko mode: Symmetries and decay rate
… Thus, we identify the Tkachenko mode with a NambuGoldstone boson of a noncommutative
field theory. We now show that this field is a compact scalar that shifts under the particle …Effective theories for many-body systems with nonuniform symmetries
A Głódkowski - arXiv preprint arXiv:2607.09427, 2026 - arxiv.org… Their existence follows from Goldstone’s theorem, while their … a correspondence between
massless Goldstone modes and broken … The celebrated Goldstone theorem states that for each …Noncommutative effective field theory of the lowest Landau level superfluid
N Manoj - Physical Review B, 2025 - APS… We will call this a noncommutative function or a noncommutative field, interchangeably
depending on the context (we refer the reader to Ref. [17] for an extensive review, and Appendix …Quadrupole conserving dynamics in the noncommutative plane
… the noncommutative plane R2 with dipole and quadrupole conservation. Dynamics in this
noncommutative … In fact, we will argue that this theory of quadrupole-conserving dynamics is as …[PDF] Tkachenko wave: From modern field theory viewpoint
… • We developed a noncommutative effective field theory of the Tkachenko mode that
predicts a cubic dependence of the decay width of the Tkachenko mode on its energy. …Conformal and noncommutative gravity from gauge symmetry breaking and SO (2, 16) unification
S Stefas, G Zoupanos - arXiv preprint arXiv:2608.23220, 2026 - arxiv.org… theory, we review the gauge-theoretic construction of Conformal Gravity and of Noncommutative
… described by an SO(10) Grand Unified Theory, based on the critical observation that the …An efficient and exact noncommutative quantum Gibbs sampler
Preparing thermal and ground states is an essential quantum algorithmic task for quantum
simulation. In this work, we construct the first efficiently implementable and exactly detailed-…Non-orientable order and non-commutative response in frustrated metamaterials
… Here, combining mechanical experiments and theory, we demonstrate that globally frustrated
matter realizes an uncharted class of classical order: non-orientable order. Our goal is to …Non-commutative Dynamic Approaches to the Kibble-Zurek Scaling Limit with an Initial Gapless Order
… This non-commutative property makes m2 still strongly depends … scaling theory with a gapless
ordered initial state. … The non-commutative approaches to the scaling limit revealed by our …Mass spectra of charged mesons and the quenching of vector meson condensation via exact phase-space diagonalization
J Chao, K Xu - Physical Review D, 2026 - APS… This identity preserves the generalized Goldstone theorem, causing the πþ pole mass to track
… IV, we extend the tensor noncommutative framework to the vector channel, exploring the …