
Dynamical Asymmetries, the Bayes’ Theorem, Entanglement,
and Intentionality in the Brain Functional Activity
David Bernal-Casas 1,† and Giuseppe Vitiello
Fractals, coherent states and self-similarity induced noncommutative geometry Giuseppe Vitiello


Giuseppe Vitiello (born 1946) is an Italian theoretical physicist and Professor Emeritus at the University of Salerno



Spatial amplitude
modulated (AM) patterns with carrier frequencies in the beta and gamma ranges (12–
80 Hz) form during the active state and dissolve as the cortex returns to its receiving state
after transmission. .... each spatial AM pattern is described to be consequent to spontaneous
breakdown of symmetry (SBS) triggered by external stimulus and is associated with one of
the emerging unitarily inequivalent ground states. Their sequencing is associated with the
non-unitary time evolution implied by dissipation, as discussed below.
details of the SBS mechanism in quantum field theory (QFT) and of the
observational techniques are presented in appendices A and B, respectively
The main ingredient of the model is thus the mechanism of SBS by which long range
correlations (the Nambu–Goldstone, briefly NG, boson modes) are dynamically generated (see
appendix A). Water constitutes more than 80% to brain mass, and in the many-body model it
is, therefore, expected to be a major facilitator or constraint on brain dynamics. The symmetry
which gets broken is the rotational symmetry of the electric dipole vibrational field of the
water molecules and of other biomolecules present in the brain structures [28, 34, 35]. The
quantum variables are identified with those of the electric dipole vibrational field and with
the associated NG modes, named the dipole wave quanta (DWQ). These are dynamically
created and are not derived from Coulomb interaction.
SBS
guarantees the change of scale, from the microscopic dynamics to the macroscopic order
parameter field. The density value of the condensation of DWQ in the ground state (also
called vacuum state) acts as a label classifying the state and thus the memory thereby created.
The stored memory is not a representation of the stimulus, nor is it a collection of stimulus
features. Indeed, a specific feature of the SBS mechanism in QFT is that the ordered pattern
generated is controlled by the inner dynamics of the system, not by the external field (stimulus)
whose only effect is the breakdown of the symmetry.
This analysis brings us to an interesting feature: any electric disturbance pro-
duced, for instance, by thermally fluctuating dipoles or by any other source, gets
confined inside filaments. Therefore ordering is preserved outside the filaments and
is disrupted only inside. In this way electromagnetic fields are allowed to propagate
only within a network of filaments so that the whole structure is shielded against
unwanted disruptive Coulomb repulsive forces. Moreover, the confinement of the
electromagnetic field provides interfaces where strong field gradients are available.
These inhomogeneities have very far-reaching consequences, as discussed elsewhere
[7]; they can produce condensation or rarefaction of selected molecules [8].








In 1995, Vitiello proposed squeezed coherent states involving NG bosons in a
dissipative model of QBD regarding a brain as an open system [8]. The heterogeneity of
memories can be represented by diverse unitarily inequivalent squeezed coherent states
emerging due to infinite degrees of freedom in QFT.
The squeezing observed in each HO occurs by a phase
difference of π, due to the different exponential factor in
equations (16).
Looking at only one HO, the missing information is
completely absorbed by the other, once it flows recursively
from one to the other although it is globally conserved, since
the system is isentropic, as was already discussed, in a similar
context, for two interacting modes of the electromagnetic
field, in [26, 27].
Our results also reinforce previous analysis where the
noncummutativity effects of variables can be considered
when addressing the issues of the fine tuning of quantum
effects. Squeezing and quantum dissipation properties
[28, 29] and a set of analogous results outside the scope of the
NC can also be found in the study of a SU (1, 1) structure of
squeezed states as damped oscillators [30] dynamically gen-
erated by single-mode Hamiltonians characterized by two-
photon process interactions, with damping elements similar to
that exhibited by equation (10). Recently, the self-similarity
properties of fractals have been discussed in the context of the
theory of entire analytical functions and of deformed algebra
of coherent states [31], and their functional realization in
terms of squeezed coherent states has been obtained. The
noncommutativity in the phase space reported here changes
the similar dynamics of two uncoupled 1D HOs (Hadamardʼs
billard) into the dynamics of coupled logarithmic spirals.
Coherent quantum squeezing due to the phase space noncommutativity
The vacuum is a coherent condensate
of NG modes. Coherence, i.e. ordering, is a global property of
the system induced by the mechanism of SBS. The system com-
ponents in this way manifest themselves as a "whole" in the macro-
scopic collective behavior. This is characterized by the value of a
field, the order parameter, which measures the density of the con-
densation of NG modes. Due to coherence property of the vac-
uum condensate, the order parameter is independent from quan-
tum fluctuations thus behaving as a classical field.
The order parameter acts as a label for the infinite number of
physically inequivalent spaces of states (unitarily inequivalent rep-
resentations) existing in QFT (in contrast, the state spaces in quan-
tum mechanics (QM) are physically (unitarily) equivalent). A tran-
sition through inequivalent state spaces is called a "phase transi-
tion". This is a critical process since different state spaces are,
as said, unitarily inequivalent. Criticality thus characterizes phase
transition processes.
2020
of phase transitions is also enhanced in sleeping, meditation, under
psychoactive substances, etc., whenever the openness of the brain
is reduced. In such cases, a flow of images from memories may be
experienced like in dreams and non-ordinary brain states (Re and
Vitiello, 2020a,b). This is consistent with the proposal, within the
DQMB, that the consciousness act lives in the dialog of the self
with its Double (Vitiello, 1995, 2001). The physical grounds for
the consciousness phenomenon are in the dissipative character of
the brain dynamics and the coherent structure of the brain states.
Partial or total lack of these conditions may lead to unconscious
brain states.
Abstract
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0375960183905091?via%3Dihub
Holographic Brain Theory: Super-Radiance, Memory Capacity and Control Theory
https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/25/4/2399
The collaborators of Pribram were Jibu and Yasue who proposed the concrete degrees of freedom in Quantum Brain Dynamics (QBD), that is Quantum Field Theory (QFT) of the brain, namely water electric dipole fields and photon fields [4,17,18,19,20,21]. Quantum Field Theory (QFT) of the brain is one of the hypotheses expected to explain formation of memory in the brain. QFT, which is distinguished from quantum mechanics, is applied to describe both microscopic degrees of freedom in quantum mechanical sense and macroscopic matter in the sense of classical physics [22]. This is called the Jibu–Yasue approach, which is distinguished from the Penrose–Hameroff approach to consciousness [23,24]...
Or, we might adopt a dissipative quantum brain theory with squeezed coherent states of Nambu–Goldstone bosons in open systems [44], which is equivalent to fractal functional representations as earlier proposed by Vitiello [45,46].
citing Vitiello, G. Fractals, coherent states and self-similarity induced noncommutative geometry. Phys. Lett. A 2012, 376, 2527–2532. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [Scilit]
https://arxiv.org/pdf/2606.30890
Consequently, the periodicity identified below reflects
a genuine physical property of the system and persists
when observables are expressed in terms of the original
noncommutative variables. In particular, the observables
considered in the present work are constructed from the
Hamiltonian and its associated operators, and therefore
inherit this representation independence.
In this representation, the noncommutative deforma-
tion is effectively shifted from the algebra to the Hamil-
tonian, where it manifests as additional interaction terms
encoding the underlying spin-induced structure.
some aspects of noncommutative
geometry implicit in the fractal generation are also considered.
In 1995, Vitiello showed that our brain has a huge memory capacity by considering our brain as an open system and using two-mode squeezed coherent states for Nambu–Goldstone bosons [36]. He also suggested that squeezed coherent states correspond to fractals in nature [37,38]. Fractality of holography might be related to squeezed coherent states in dissipative systems.
https://www.mdpi.com/2673-9321/4/2/19
Vitiello, 2012, 2014), showing indeed the isomorphism
between scale free self-similar structures and deformed
coherent states, the self-similarity found in the spectral
analysis signals the coherent dynamics of the cells in the
cluster. Cellular coherence is also confirmed by additional
studies (Cherubini et al., 2015) on interacting beta cells
subclusters showing that there exists a ‘‘functional coordin-
ation geography’’ in this peculiar system which goes well
beyond the simple spatial pattern of cellular communication.......
.............
the self-similarity properties observed in the experiments reflect the
self-similarity properties of the SU (1, 1) thermal states. In this connection, we ob-
serve that a SU (1, 1) coherent state representation related to dissipative processes
can also be exhibited1 where the notion of topologically nontrivial dissipative phase
is introduced and the dynamics is characterized by noncommutative geometry in the
plane. .
............
At a quantum level, dissipation induces noncommutative geometry with the
squeezing parameter playing a relevant role. Ubiquity of fractals in Nature and relevance of
coherent states and electromagnetic interaction point to a unified, integrated vision of Nature.
...............
Let me close this Section with a comment on noncommutative geometry arising as an effect of
dissipation [30]. In the (z1, z2) plane use the notation + ≡ 1 and − ≡ 2, so that pz± denote the
momenta and v± = ˙z± the forward in time and backward in time velocities:
v± = 1
m (pz∓ ∓ 1
2γz±) , with [v+, v−] = −i γ
m2 (45)
The relation between dissipation and noncommutative geometry in the plane is thus obtained since the
canonical set of conjugate position coordinates (ξ+, ξ−) can be then defined by putting ξ± = ∓(m/γ)v±,
with
[ξ+, ξ−] = i 1
γ (46)
The area S enclosed in the two paths P1 and P2 is proportional to the quantum dissipative interference
phase ϑ = S γ in the noncommutative plane, provided z+ 6 = z−.
On the other hand, the algebraic structure of the doubling of the degrees of freedom introduced above
in order to close the system is a noncommutative one. The algebra is indeed duplicated by the map
A → A1 ⊗ A2, which is the Hopf coproduct map A → A ⊗ 1 + 1 ⊗ A.
..................
Nature appears to be modulated by coherence, rather than being hierarchically layered in isolated
compartments, in multi-coded collections of isolated systems and phenomena [5,34]. One might express
this by saying that the dynamics of coherence is the primordial origin of codes. In this way codes
are promoted from the (syntactic) level of pure information (à la Shannon) to the (semantic) level of
meanings, expressions of coherent dynamical processes
..........
https://www.mdpi.com/2079-8954/2/2/203
It has been shown [48,57,58] that an isomorphism exists between fractal self-similarity
and coherent states in QFT, and therefore, between the fractal dimension and the entropy
associated with the coherent condensate (cf. Appendix A.2).
...............
https://www.mdpi.com/2313-7673/8/1/122
Feng, Q.; Wang, L.; Chen, Y.; Teng, J.; Li, M.; Cai, Z.; Niu, X.; Rein, G.; Yang, Q.; Shao, X.; et al. Effects of different music on
HEK293T cell growth and mitochondrial functions. Explore 2022, 18, 670–675. [CrossRef]
Effects of different music on HEK293T cell growth and mitochondrial functions
- Qian Feng
- Lin Wang
- Yu Chen
- Jie Teng
- Mengmei Li
- Zhongzhen Cai
- Xiaoguo Niu
- Glen Rein
- Qiaoli Yang
- Xiaoqian Shao
- Chao Zhang
- Xuemei Bai
Highlights
Three different types of music showed different effect on specific biochemical measures in cultured human embryonic kidney cells.
Five-element music significantly enhanced adenosine triphosphate (ATP), glutathione (GSH) and cells growth rates while reducing the reactive oxygen species (ROS) of cells.
Classical music increased GSH and cells growth significantly.
Heavy-metal music had an opposite and significant effect on cells with a 16% increase in ROS and 11% reduction in cell viability.
Abstract
Background: Mitochondria are considered a portal to receive, process and integrate external energy and information to maintain cellular homeostasis. Previous studies demonstrated that mitochondrial function and antioxidant capacity of in-vitro cultured mammalian cells is modified by different energetic stimuli including electromagnetic energy, acoustic energy, external Qi and subtle energy emitted by written texts in relatively short time frames. Thus, individual cells can act as a rapid and sensitive biological sensor and act as a platform to evaluate and understand the subtle effect of different biophysical stimuli. Regarding acoustic energy, several different types of music have been reported to produce beneficial effects on human health.
Objective: To compare eastern and western music styles on cell function at the biochemical level to understand the underlying mechanisms involved.
Methods In this study, we compared the effects of Chinese five-element music with two types of western music (heavy-metal and classical) on mitochondrial function, oxidative capacity and growth using HEK293T cells (human embryonic kidney cells).
Results: Unlike rock and classical music, exposing cells to five-element music produced several beneficial physiological effects, including statistically significant increases in the production of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) by 17%, glutathione (GSH) by 21% and cell growth rates (14%), as well as a significant reduction in the reactive oxygen species (ROS) by 13%. For the group treated with classical music, there was only a trend toward increased GSH (8%), although the increased growth rates (14%) did reach significance. In sharp contrast, the cells treated with heavy-metal music responded with an opposite and significant 16% increase in ROS and a significant 11% reduction in cell viability.
Conclusions: This study revealed the dramatically different and even opposite effects of different styles of music on specific biochemical measures in cultured human cells. These results help explain the underlying biochemical mechanisms of the effects of the different types of music.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0965229925000743
The significant benefits of five-element music therapy in improving emotions in Chinese patients undergoing maintenance hemodialysis highlight the importance of culturally tailored interventions.
Gong, Shang, Jiao (often spelled Jue), Zhi, and Yu are the five core tones (wǔyīn) of the traditional Chinese pentatonic scale. They map roughly to Do, Re, Mi, Sol, and La (or 1, 2, 3, 5, and 6 in numbered notation) as a melodic approximation rather than an exact fixed pitch- Five notes: It uses the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 5th, and 6th degrees of a major scale.
- Missing notes: It leaves out Fa (4th) and Ti (7th), removing half-step tension and dissonant intervals.
- Example in C major: C, D, E, G, and A.
- The role of
the phonons (i.e., the quanta of the sound waves) has been considered, providing a deeper
understanding of the interaction of sound waves with cells. Moreover, the theoretical
modeling can account for the experimental observation of the fractal and multifractal
self-similarity [9] in the response signals of cells to sound stimuli. An isomorphism has
been found between the coherent state molecular regime and fractal and multifractal
structures [10].
Several specific mechanisms can be invoked, such as phase locking and phase content
in the dynamics of the molecular components and the water bath in which molecules and
cells are embedded [11–15]. Additionally, non-trivial topological properties may have an
important role in the molecular dynamical properties [14–17]. Our review will include an
illustration of the QFT spontaneous breakdown of symmetry (SBS), a mechanism that is
the basis of most theoretical and experimental physics. Ordered patterns and organization
appear as a consequence of SBS [18–22]. - The mentioned isomorphism between fractal self-similarity and coherent states sug-
gests that the experimentally observed fractal structures reported in the previous section
are manifestations of the coherent dynamics of the long-range dipole correlations. Such
processes of ordering are processes generating forms with fractal properties. It is then
intriguing to think of them as morphogenesis processes [10]. This might shed some light
indeed on the morphogenesis dynamics, a problem (at least) not completely solved in
biomolecular studies. Moreover, along a similar line of thought, we are also motivated to
study the transitions through different ordered states (phase transitions) as processes from
form to form and think of them as metamorphosis processes [14,15,23], so recurrent in the life,
i.e., the time evolution, of biological systems.
Finally, the experimental observation that cells react with the same responses to
different persons’ vocal sounds suggests that cells’ response is induced not by individual
frequencies, voiceprint, and tones, but by their collective envelope. In this way, cells perform
very fast and efficient transitions from the syntactic unit’s level (individual frequencies) to
the semantic level, a not easy task to be achieved by an ‘artificial’ device. - https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/23/9/5145
- Suppose now to “break the symmetry” by introducing a suffix to the A’s, A1 A2 A3 . . .
or A1 BA2. Differences then appear when the A’s positions are exchanged, A1 A2 A3 . . . is
different from A2 A1 A3 . . ., etc., and A1 BA2̸ = A2 BA1. The different “ordering” of the A’s
corresponding to their indices now carries non-empty information.
Thus, we see that the (indices) diversity allows ordering, and vice versa, order implies
diversity, i.e., the possibility of distinguishing elements in the set.
- ince the flows exiting (out) from the system are entering (in) the environment, and
vice versa, the set (Ak, ˜Ak) is a closed set, and the environment describes the image
“inverted in the time” of the system, as in a ’mirror of time’, its “Double” [6,7].
We note that the doubling of the degrees of freedom consists in the doubling of the
state space H → H × H, and of the operator algebra A → A × A. We have then the
q−deformed Hopf algebra with non-commutative co-product ∆A = A × q + q−1 × A,
where q = eθ for bosons (or q = eiθ for fermions).
The asymmetry between (A × q) and (q−1 × A), implicit in the non-commutativity of
∆A under exchange of (A × q) ↔ (q−1 × A), allows the possibility to distinguish between
the system and its environment [44], and plays thus a crucial role in the self-identification
process characterizing the brain activity in relation with its environment.
Since the Bogoliubov transformations (Equations (A6) and (A7)), on which the con-
struction of the dissipative model is based, can be obtained from the co-product ∆A,
with q = eθ , we see that its non-commutativity is at the origin of the brain dynamical
asymmetries under time translation and time-reversal transformations (the arrow of time) -




