Wednesday, June 7, 2023

France's Nuclear Power is not a "model" for global warming energy: John LaForge of NukeWatch Info (Wisconsin)

 https://www.counterpunch.org/2023/06/12/frances-global-warming-predicament/

Source: https://nukewatchinfo.org/

 In France, reactors shutdown due to lack of cooling water from rising temperatures and dried up rivers.

Half of France’s 56 reactors shuttered for repairs, and its nuclear energy production fell by 30%, leaving one of the world’s most nuclear-powered nations a net importer of energy in 2022.
The former heads of nuclear power regulation in the U.S., Germany, France, and the U.K. issued a joint statement outlining why nuclear power is not the answer to climate chaos and is not a viable nor sustainable source of energy for the health of people or planet. After years of work inside the industry, they should know. The four leaders issuing the joint statement are: Dr. Greg Jaczko, former Chairman of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission, and founder of Maxean, an energy company; Prof. Wolfgang Renneberg, a university professor and former Head of Reactor Safety, Radiation Protection, and Nuclear Waste for Germany’s Federal Environment Ministry; Dr. Bernard Laponche, a French engineer and author, former Director General for the French Agency for Energy Management, and former Advisor to French Minister of Environment, Energy, and Nuclear Safety; Dr. Paul Dorfman, an associate fellow and researcher at the University of Sussex and former secretary to the U.K. Government. Committee Examining Radiation Risk from Internal Emitters.
Almost all sodium-cooled reactors constructed around the world have experienced sodium leaks, likely because of chemical interactions between sodium and the stainless steel used in various components. Having to deal with all these volatile properties and safety concerns naturally drives up the construction costs of fast reactors, rendering them substantially more expensive than common thermal reactors. Sodium-cooled reactors … operat[e] at dismally low rates compared to standard reactors, the [fuel] load factor … for the Prototype Fast Reactor in the United Kingdom was 27%; France’s Superphenix reactor managed a mere 7.9%. The typical US reactor operates with a load factor of more than 90%.
President Emmanuel Macron of France once said that “without civil nuclear power, there is no military nuclear power, and without military nuclear power, there is no civil nuclear power.”
EDF, France’s largely state-owned nuclear reactor agency, temporarily shut down 15 reactors after cracks were discovered in emergency cooling circuits a year ago. The company had to halt production in others to allow for upgrades and as a result of the overheated climate. Rising temperatures have rendered France’s river water too warm to cool its reactors and waste fuel. The shutdowns are consequential in a country that boasts the world’s largest percentage of nuclear power production compared to other electricity sources. The cooling circuit cracks are reported to have been caused by stress corrosion and faulty welded seals: severely dangerous flaws that could lead to a loss-of-coolant and meltdowns. As reactors are currently being inspected and repaired, fixes are moving slowly. Replacement components need to be readjusted regularly, EDF said to Reuters. Many of the reactors are approaching the end of their 40-year licenses, but EDF is considering 10-year license extensions. Due to the location of the problems, workers carrying out the hazardous duty are exposed to higher doses of ionizing radiation. Consequently, government contractors have arbitrarily raised the allowable maximum dose limit, relaxing rules they said were overly protective in any case. France hopes to have all the reactors back on line by February 2023.
Reuters, Sept. 16; The Guardian, Aug. 3; New York Times, June 18; Express.co.uk, June 15, 2022

No comments:

Post a Comment