Thursday, November 10, 2022

Tim Maudlin vid discussion and my responses

 Tim Maudlin vid

Tim Maudlin got the author wrong of "The Mathematics of Plato's Academy" - it's David Fowler, not Donald Fowler. "...the manipulations of music theory seem to depend fundamentally on the operation of compounding, an operation which seems to pose some serious problems for mathematicians. My purely speculative suggestion...is that music theory might plausibly give some help with this problem." David Fowler, The Mathematics of Plato's Academy: A New Reconstruction, Oxford: Clarendon Press, (1987); paperback edition, (1989). Second ed., with addenda, (1999). Fowler didn't realize that noncommutativity solves this problem - and Tim Maudlin doesn't realize this either. See Math Professor Luigi Borzacchini's debate with David Fowler on the music theory origins of Western math that Borzacchini calls a "deep, pre-established disharmony." I don't think Maudlin understands Plato properly since Plato is using the wrong music theory from Archytas and Philolaus as the basis of "alogon."
Retrocausality is not worse - Olivier Costa de Beauregard was the FIRST to propose retrocausality.
If mathematics made such good predictions then why is there such a severe ecological crisis that Earth faces biological annihilation in one decade? Roger Penrose answers this question that most scientists would never even acknowledge: Gravitational entropy is the opposite of the entropy of matter and gravitational entropy is due to mass originating from noncommutative time-frequency.
Carlo Rovelli also said that "quantum biology is shit" - which means that the Royal Society should not have given their "science book of the year" award to Professor JOhnJoe McFadden's book on quantum biology in 2016, "Life on the Edge." oops. Quantum biology is definitely not crap - just ask Roger Penrose.
Protoconsciousness is not the same as observing. Listening is up to ten times faster than Fourier Uncertainty - as proven by science. The highest sound we hear externally resonates the brain internally as ultrasound - proven in tinnitus research. The ultrasound resonates as quantum nonlocal coherence via the microtubules and tubuluin, proven by Dr. Anirban Bandyopadhyay.
Alain Connes relies on Heisenberg and matrices - not the wavefunction. As Basil J. Hiley emphasizes there's no need to use a wavefunction in quantum physics.
Von Neumann uses Process I and II and II not "A and B" - see Alain Connes' lecture on quantum randomness for details. I did a transcription of it.
entropy originates out of noncommutativity as Alain Connes explains.
the passage of time emerges out of noncommutativity.
The UnDivided Universe was co-written with Professor Basil J. Hiley who has extended David Bohm's model as based on noncommutativity.
 
 Michael Perrone
An important perspective! Wave function collapse only happens because of the assumptions we make about what constitutes a measurement: check out weak measurement theory. The wave function COLLAPSE is epistemic; not the wave function.
5
Taking into account also the wave function of the measurement system there is no Wave Function Collapse/Jump, or at most nothing higher than an order of the Plank constant.
1
 @Farhad Towfiq  That's a good way of looking at it
Professor Basil J. Hiley says there's no need to use the wave function nor any need for a wave function collapse - rather use noncommutative time-frequency nonlocality. 
 
 

No comments:

Post a Comment