when Chomsky says you can only study the digestive system, a major nervous system, from the outside only - that is disproven by meditation training. For example Wim Hof has been proven by Western science studies that the digestive immune system and digestive nervous system can be controlled internally - using breathing and mental concentration. That's just a start of that type of training. A good quantum biology article on the digestive system is by Professor Jack Tuszynski of Canada - well his research group I mean: The gastrointestinal-brain axis in humans as an evolutionary advance of the root-leaf axis in plants: A hypothesis linking quantum effects of light on serotonin and auxin March 2018 Journal of Integrative Neuroscience 17(2):227-237 DOI:10.3233/JIN-170048
"just as we can't become conscious of how our digestive system works...if you want to study how it works and it is a major nervous system...you have to study it from a third person point of view from the outside and the same is true of our mental life."
52 minutes in....
Chomsky says there are
"internal thoughts that we struggle to articulate."Yes that is true but do we have to put something into words to know what it is?
So he says, "inner speech" is actually the same as "outer speech."
So he says, if you introspect you get "bits and pieces" - "instanteously" - in "very complicated ways."
He says, "we're not conscious of it but it's all going on in everything we do." - This is what Penrose refers to as Protoconsciousness and that it's from the future guiding us.
A lot of "mental computation going on... bits and pieces of it reaching awareness...fragments usually but so interpenetrated with what's conscious that you just can study them separately"...
Chomsky is referring to what Roger Penrose calls "protoconsciousness" from Bernard 'd Espagnat. He says that the mental computations are interpenetrated and can't be separated - I have discussed this with Chomsky via email. This is the noncommutativity math that Penrose relies on to explain protoconsciousness and it is explained - noncommutativity by Fields Medal math Professor Alain Connes.
What's conscious can't be disentangled from what's unconscious...
"It's the same internal system. So if we keep to the internal system, the core of language, turns out it pays NO ATTENTION to things like linear order; only pays attention to the structure of expressions, which has a very funny consequence: It means your children, for example, when they are acquiring language, pay NO ATTENTION to 100% of what they hear, and ONLY pay attention to what they NEVER HEAR. They hear things in linear order but the rules that they use pay attention to structure which they don't hear, they construct it in their minds."
"Let me ask you a question. When you're typing a letter, not paying a lot of attention; just typing, not paying much attention. Do you ever notice that you make typographical errors, where you type a word that sounds the same way? Like, suppose you're planning to say write but you write, right?...Happens to me too. I think what it means is you're HEARING the things. You're writing but you're actually HEARING. And that writing is a kind of very peripheral activity and HEARING is much DEEPER EMBEDDED.
"...So actually when you're doing something like typing you're often just HEARING yourself. That's why you make mistakes like that. Are their differences in the way people do this? "
So in fact this is just logical inference of noncommutativity as de Broglie's Law of Phase Harmony. Check out Fields Medal Math Professor Alain Connes lectures on "the music of shapes" and his noncommutative geometry lectures. He's arguing that because the inner cross products of the matrices are unobservable as Heisenberg discovered therefore they are the inherent organizing infinity that is also negative entropy. We perceive them as random since we can only observe them after the fact. But we can LISTEN to them since we can listen to music, as proven by science, up to ten times faster than Fourier Uncertainty.
in fact, an infant doesn't pay attention to 100% of what it hears, linear order. It pays attention to what it NEVER HEARS, the structure that it brains constructs: which is a pretty dramatic finding."
No comments:
Post a Comment