Wednesday, December 1, 2021

More Alain Connes on Music

 Connes says how he loved his grandmother who was a pianist....

 https://celebratio.org/Connes_A/article/842/

 Connes: When I was five years old I began piano lessons, and I really loved it. But when we moved to Marseille, we could not have a piano in the house. My father told me I had to choose between music and studies. So I dropped the piano then. I of course always regretted immensely to have done that. When I was twenty, I started again to play the piano, but of course I had missed the most important years for learning. I have done a lot of work to recover from that, but I never recovered to the point that I would have been at. But okay — this is life.

Jackson: You can’t do everything.

Connes: You can’t do everything. I now see very well that I have a part of the brain that is musical. In fact I just wrote a paper for the Journal of Mathematics and Music. But I know that the part of the brain that is occupied by music is sort of competing with the part that is occupied by mathematics. Of course, they are extremely close. This might sound strange, but often I learn a lot in mathematics by studying scores of music.

Jackson: How does that happen?

Connes: In mathematics, you might in some cases have the impression that you have reached the highest level of sophistication. But then you study a great musical score, and you find that the composer has a level of sophistication that is about twice the level of sophistication of the best mathematics. This is what I have in mind. There are composers, especially of the Romantic period, who have reached a level of musical precision that I always find comforting and a source of energy to do mathematics. So I use musical scores as a source of sophistication, but I also like to improvise and to let things out.

Jackson: And the singing when you were at the Ecole Normale?

Connes: That was poor singing, Corsican songs! It was just for fun. I had a happy temperament, especially coming from the south of France and finding myself in Paris, where people were much more intellectual. 

....

These things exist in the brain, and they send you signals. Similarly in music, you can have something that exists in your mind, a tune or a theme. This is something amazing and very hard to define.

Algebra is much more time-dependent and evolving. In algebra, when you are doing computations, there is a definite analogy with the time dependence in music, which is extremely striking.

 The noncommutativity, which was discovered by people in quantum mechanics, in fact is a generator of time. I am still thinking about the fact that the passage of time, or the way we feel that time is going on and we cannot stop it, is in fact exactly the consequence of the noncommutativity of quantum mechanics

 Something Heisenberg discovered, which is absolutely amazing, is that when you repeat certain microscopic experiments, the results will never be the same.

 When you permute A and B, and you make the A pass on the other side, you have to make it evolve with time. And the time in which it has to evolve is in fact the purely imaginary number . This is what is behind the scenes. 

This means that the notion of causality, or the notion of time, is totally upset by the phenomenon of entanglement. I interpret it as meaning that there is something more primitive than the passing of time,

 

The de BROGLIE wave in the solutions of DIRAC equation https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-02448288/document The wavelength of de BROGLIE is obtained by considering the wavelength of the phase wave. It is also the wavelength of the wave function that appears in the exact solutions to the DIRAC equation....DIRAC's equation is invariant by a change of frame under the LORENTZ transformation, which guarantees its total compatibility with de BROGLIE's phase harmony theorem, which is itself established on purely relativistic bases....
Now, in many of his previous papers Sidharth [42, 43] has argued that noncommutativity is a characteristic attribute of the zitterbewegung region. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1911.01360.pdf
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1610.10083.pdf The noncommutative geometry of Zitterbewegung
8:01 "Clef" is just French for "key" (though you'll often see it spelled "clé", which is how we generally pronounce it today).
1
thanks - yes that makes sense. I studied orchestration as a teenager - and it is transposing different keys of music. It's been over 30 years so my nomenclature is rusty. haha. I was referring to Connes discussion from his book "Triangle of Thoughts" - it's online. "read music scores and hear multiple texts in their head “that is inscribed in a time that would no longer be sequential, because a score is a multitude of chords, a tangle projected onto physical time of course, but that manifestly evolves in an higher dimensional space, giving rise to a variability much more pertinent to the description of individual time.” and https://www.ems-ph.org/journals/newsletter/pdf/2008-03-67.pdf https://mathrising.com/?p=317 https://www.valdostamuseum.com/hamsmith/musPhys.html "Musical notation allows several themes to be developed simultaneously. Several melodies can coexist and a dialogue can be established in the same instant; polyphony is a dialogue that is simultaneous, not sequential. In this sense, I think that music is an outline of a language that is inscribed in a multi-dimensional not sequential framework;" I remember having heard the conductor Solti explain how he prepared for a concert. ... he simply took the score and holed up in a room where he would spend hours reading the score in silence." that is inscribed in a time that would no longer be sequential, because a score is a multitude of chords, a tangle projected onto physical time of course, but that manifestly evolves in an higher dimensional space ..." reading a page of polyphony, as does a conductor, is much more difficult." And it could be formalized by music."

 

No comments:

Post a Comment