Saturday, November 14, 2020

Werner Herzog's Ecstatic Truth or Postmodern B.S.: The Minnesota Declaration Debunked

 Here we have a review of film maker Werner Herzog's career - youtube

So it focuses on his Minnesota Declaration of his philosophy of film making about "Ecstatic Truth." This is a kind of existential transcendence he claims to capture in film ( I realize "existential transcendence" is an oxymoronic phrase in Western philosophy).

 Each year at springtime scores of people on snowmobiles crash through the melting ice on the lakes of Minnesota and drown.

No Herzog - this is not true but it fits with his insistence on including dramatized commentary in his "documentaries." 

http://files.dnr.state.mn.us/education_safety/safety/ice/ice_stats.pdf 

So rarely do a dozen people die by ice in Minnesota a year - usually it's just a few people.

"I make films because I have not learned anything else" - 

his intonation sounds precisely like Nosferatu in his film. hilarious.

So I recently watched Nosferatu but then someone insisted that the English translation does not do justice to the film - or I mean the English DUBBING. And they offered a German comparison (translated into English).

 Peter Huber

Every scene was filmed twice - once in German, once in English. This is, of course, the English version and a weaker version, IMO. The German version is a much more enjoyable film because it's the actor's native language.
3
does the german version have subtitles?
@Voidisyinyang Voidisyinyang Yes - look for a DVD or BluRay copy.
@Peter Huber thanks - so the English translation of the German was better than the dubbed English.
 The question is - does the German version have more of an "ecstatic truth" experience than the English dubbing?

 
So Herzog has been proven correct - as I blogged recently - that indeed fish grew the genetic adaptation of legs in order to escape predators by crawling onto rocks - and eventually this became permanent.
 
But then Herzog states the Moon is Dull - so he is obviously cut off from the cycles of life as governed by the Moon's power over water on Earth.
 
Meaning Herzog is psychologically projecting a kind of patriarchal solar priest male fantasy - this was easily conveyed by Nazism of course but goes back to Platonic Christianity as well - and even the Buddhism he critiques. Acharya S. has her book "Suns of Gods" for details.
 
 
So Herzog is struggling to move past Postmodernism - similarly as Zizek does.
 
So the Echidna is featured in the review.  Ironically the Echidna, as I have detailed previously, has a LARGER prefrontal cortex than humans, as per ratio of total brain size. The problem though is the Echidna lacks REM sleep so there is no way for the Echidna to integrate the intentional linear planning of a prefrontal cortex with the subconscious perceptions that are constantly ongoing via the dream "biophoton" holographic reality of being awake.

So the question remains for Herzog - what is the TRUTH of reality but the problem is that Herzog has spent his life "acquiring images" as he calls it - he must ACQUIRE IMAGES - he repeats over and over - that the world lacks appropriate images. But the truth can NEVER EVER be shown through an image. haha. So this idea of Time as the Image of Eternity is from Plato and based on the "deep pre-established disharmony" of Western philosophy from the wrong symmetric geometric magnitude math.
 
  yes the West is based on what archaeologists call the "symbolic revolution" to "contain infinity" using anthropocentric rectilinear geometry. Professor Alfred Crosby's book "Ecological Imperialism" details how the past 500 years of spreading Western civilization around the world has been based on ecocide and genocide, primarily through the spread of pandemics due to intensive animal farming. So David F. Noble's book "The Religion of Technology" expands on this notion - he was formerly a MIT Professor - and such "evolution of technology" (title of a Cambridge book) is based on a "deep pre-established disharmony" (math professor Luigi Borzacchini) going back to Plato. So luckily Mother Nature is now taking revenge as scientists have documented the East Siberian Arctic Shelf methane bomb has been triggered - http://arctic-news.blogspot.com so soon abrupt global warming will double and it will be too hot to grow food on scale. Modern humans have taken down the rest of life as we destroy our own as well. Our original human culture, the San Bushmen, knew how to live without rape nor warfare - as the book "The Harmless People" documents - by anthropologist Elizabeth Marshall Thomas. Other anthropologists have tried to cover up the book. Dr Bradford Keeney gives further follow up. The San Bushmen spread around the world and are from before 70,000 BCE - so they should be studied in detail yet they remain the least known about. Kind of funny.
 

Voidisyinyang Voidisyinyang
The Weak measurements deal with just one variable as a vector BEFORE any eigenfunction is created. So it's using Heisenberg math as Yakir Aharonov explains. Kafatos just doesn't understand the science from Yakir Aharonov but Aharonov has a whole school of scientists who work with him. Yakir Aharonov: "There is a non-local exchange that depends on the modular variable....I'm saying that I have now an intuitive picture to understand interference by saying that when a particle moves through two slits, it always goes through one slit or the other, but it knows which other slit, the slit through which it did not go, whether it is open or not, because there are nonlocal equations of motion." Finally making sense of the double-slit experiment (2017, Aharonov): The nonlocal equations of motion in the Heisenberg picture thus allow us to consider a particle going through only one of the slits, but it nevertheless has nonlocal information regarding the other slit.... The Heisenberg picture, however, offers a different explanation for the loss of interference that is not in the language of collapse: if one of the slits is closed by the experimenter, a nonlocal exchange of modular momentum with the particle occurs....Alternatively, in the Heisenberg picture, the particle has both a definite location and a nonlocal modular momentum that can “sense” the presence of the other slit and therefore, create interference." as John Bell states: "Is it not clear from the diffraction and interference patterns, that the motion of the particle is directed by the wave?" https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1367-2630/15/7/073022
Don Hoffman only relies on quantum mechanics AFTER the probability of the amplitude squared - so Hoffman is a computer scientist not a real quantum physicist.
Kafatos is ignoring the fact that Schroedinger was based on de Broglie's critique of relativity and now Yakir Aharonov has experimentally proven the de Broglie-Bohm model using weak measurements from Heisenberg matrice math that is noncommutative. So the Psi value of Schroedinger is not based on the truth of a single particle but only the accumulation of many particles. Yakir Aharonov published in 2017 that in fact the double slit experiment has been proven to be based on a nonlocal field that is guiding the particle - so the electon "knows" if the OTHER slit is open or not - due to this nonlocal guiding field. The fact that is noncommutative just means we can not call it a wave as spin is not a wave nor is it a particle. As Professor Basil J. Hiley, the collaborator of Bohm, points out - this is a NEW CAUSATIVE force.
 
 Voidisyinyang Voidisyinyang
the problem with the Copenhagen Interpretation is that it is anthropocentric. Noncommutative math is totally different because it does not rely on a "contained infinity" as symmetric geometry. As Sir Roger Penrose emphasizes - time was highly ASYMMETRIC at the origin of the Universe yet also highly coherent. Penrose now also promotes noncommutative geometry or quantum algebra as the truth of reality (he just admits he's not good at the math). haha.

Western science is a CONSTRUCTION but living in ecological truth is NOT a construction. In the past 10,000 years as archaeologists document there was a "symbolic revolution" in human culture to promote the idea of "containing infinity" through rectilinear anthropocentric geometry. Our original human culture, the San Bushmen, lived sustainably in the truth of ecology. The "three gunas" of India is from our original human culture in contrast to the Vedic Brahmin Chariot INVASION of India that Kafatos promotes.  

You all are arguing that vision is the perception of God but this is not the truth of reality. As Ramana Maharshi emphasized the SELF can not be SEEN - only LISTENED to as eternal logical inference. Westerners get this confused with "enlightenment" as Maharshi points out.
  Just because you're dreaming does not make the physical world a HALLUCINATION - that is just a convenient DeNile by Western arrogance. How easy to justify whatever morality you want by claiming external reality or your thoughts to be a hallucination. Rather the truth is based on harmonic vibrations as de Broglie discovered - he said his most important discovery was his Law of Phase Harmony. Yet Kafatos doesn't acknowledge the truth of the Law of Phase Harmony. It's not an illusion or hallucination - it's a harmonic resonance as truth.
 
 Voidisyinyang Voidisyinyang
Mathematics is not "more elevated" or the "most refined" - that is Platonic Religion of Technology. Math "works" but for whom? Math has created biological annihilation as the ecological crisis!! It's not "more elevated."
 
  Basil J. Hiley emphasizes you do not need Probabilities to do quantum physics - same with the Weak Measurements of Yakir Aharonov. This idealization of probabilities is just wrong.
 
 Voidisyinyang Voidisyinyang
This Anti-Body view of Vedic Caste Hierarchy got repeated by Plato - it's why the ecological pollution is so bad in India as India was just the origin of the West as DNA science proves. Vedic Brahmin philosophy is from West Asia and INVADED India via patriarchal chariots.

No comments:

Post a Comment