Monday, April 21, 2025

Two Wrongs don't make a Right: How Ukraine is the "pinchers" of far right/far left Platonic industrialized genocide

 https://consortiumnews.com/2025/04/20/in-ukraine-ultra-nationalists-are-the-good-guys/

This fascinating interview of scholar

 Dr. Marta Havryshko holds a Ph.D. in History from the Ivan Franko National University in Lviv, Ukraine.

focuses on the underlying patriarchy of the "solidarity" movements to help the Ukrainian refugees, the victims of the Russian invasion - meanwhile the Russian-Ukrainians who fought against the Nazis are being targeted with human rights abuses. So she acknowledges the original Soviet invasion was just as bad as the later Nazi invasion (that killed 1.5 million Jews) - yet both extreme patriarchal violent "sides" are now the driving force behind the war today.

 She is currently a visiting assistant professor at the Strassler Center for Holocaust and Genocide Studies at Clark University in Worcester, Massachusetts.

 I remember visiting Clark University once - not sure if I was just driving through town? Must have been on the way to Boston! Wow...

At that time, the leadership of the academic institution in Lviv where I worked contacted the Security Service of Ukraine to report my “dangerous activities.” The entire situation was absurd and grotesque, because I was being harassed not just by fringe far-right groups, but also by professors holding high academic positions. That was also the first time I experienced antisemitic verbal attacks that invoked a common trope about the alleged disloyalty of Jews to the Ukrainian national project.

After Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022, these attacks became more frequent. The attackers grew more aggressive, believing that by doing so they were “defending Ukraine.”

 https://daviscenter.fas.harvard.edu/about/people/marta-havryshko

Guest speaker at Harvard...

 Thus, the Russian-Ukrainian war resembles domestic abuse, where the abuser desperately tries to preserve his power and privileges over other family members. The vulnerability and partial dependence of these members on the patriarch—who seeks to discipline them through force—requires the intervention of external actors.

 I think this is completely accurate to blow up nationalist political movements as indicative of psycho-physiological patriarchy! The problem of ejaculation addiction writ-large as Missile Envy.

 https://consortiumnews.com/2025/04/20/on-neo-nazi-influence-in-ukraine/

 https://www.clarku.edu/faculty/profiles/marta-havryshko/ 

Effects of Sexual Violence on Women in Russia’s War on Ukraine

Annual Conference of the Population Health and Armed Conflict Network
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
October
2024
Sponsored by University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
Marta Havryshko

 Marta Havryshko new talk

 Marta Havryshko new talk part 2 

Part one talk with Marta Havryshko 

 her recent publications include a book, Overcoming Silence: Women's War Stories (2018), as well as articles such as, "Women’s Bodies as Battlefield: Sexual Violence during Soviet Counterinsurgency in Western Ukraine (1944-1953)” in Euxeinos. Governance and Culture in the Black Sea Region, 9 (2019); “Rape in Hiding: Sexual Violence during the Holocaust in Ukraine” in Holokost i Suchasnist, 17 (2019, In Ukrainian); and, “Love and Sex in Wartime: Controlling Women's Sexuality in the Ukrainian Nationalist Underground” in Aspasia, 12 (2018). Dr. Havryshko’s research has been supported by the German Academic Exchange Service (Deutscher Akademischer Austauschdienst, DAAD), Yahad-In Unum, Monash University, Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies, St. Gallen University, amongst others.

 part 1 and 2 combined

 Marta Havryshko, Institute of Modern Jewry, Hebrew University, 17 November 2021

 Soviets also did pogroms against the Jews in Ukraine

 

From Marta Havryshko, “Sexual Violence in the Holocaust: Perspectives from Ghettos and Camps in Ukraine”:

Political and ideological factors significantly contributed to the proliferation of sexual violence during the Holocaust. Sexual humiliation of the Jewish body was an inevitable consequence of the dehumanizing Nazi racial theories… Rape could be but one way to punish and humiliate the Jews. In this framework, rapists placed the blame for the rape on women themselves, believing they “deserved” it for their political choice. Consequently, women were raped not just because they were women, but specifically because they were Jewish women.

 This research project analyses the causes, patterns, dynamics, and consequences of sexual violence against Jewish women and girls during the Shoah in Ukraine using a gender approach. The main questions under consideration include: Was sexual violence a by-product or rather a tool of genocide? How and why could rape be considered an instrument of terror, humiliation, punishment, revenge, dehumanisation, demonstrating power, bonding among perpetrators, and constructing gender roles? What is sexual about sexual violence in the Holocaust?

 https://www.vwi.ac.at/index.php/en/research/fellows-rueckblick/fellows-2020-2021/gerda-henkel-research-fellow/marta-havryshko

 Dr. Marta Havryshko (Lviv/Munich). The latter brought to light the women's theme in the twentieth-century tragedies that unfolded on the territory of Ukraine.

 Dr. Marta Havryshko reveals how she was put on a "kill list" for exposing the rise of the Neo-Nazi movement in Ukraine - but that no other Ukrainian scholars have spoken in defense of her. 

So the NeoNazi movement emphasize "atrocity propaganda" of real Russian/Soviet genocidal history while ignoring or covering up the NeoNazi propaganda as "lesser evil." So people point out that the Holomodor was not exclusively focused on Ukrainians. Yes a good book on this is "Against the Peasant" - a critique of Marxist philosophy.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment